Trump wanted the power to make arrests without providing a reason. That's beyond "scary."
The Trump White House seriously studied how to "cancel" habeas corpus, your right to know why the government has arrested you.
Last year, the White House considered a proposal that could’ve enabled the president to arrest anyone, without a stated reason.
A bombshell report from two New York Times journalists reveals that the Trump administration debated suspending what’s called “habeas corpus,” the centuries-old right to force the government to explain, in front of a judge, why it has locked you up. With the president’s encouragement, senior officials in the West Wing studied whether they could switch off one of the oldest guarantees under the law by simply declaring they had the power to arrest people without justification.
While the initial focus was on speeding up mass deportation, such an order would have — in effect — cleared the way for the Trump administration to arrest anyone it wanted and prevent them from challenging their detention. We throw around words like “autocracy” and “fascism,” and at times folks dismiss them as hyperbole, but you cannot read this news without seeing how serious the situation actually is.
For those who might have forgotten, the writ of habeas corpus is what stands between a free person and arbitrary imprisonment. It’s the constitutional requirement that stops a government from being able to make you disappear. In the entire history of the American republic, it’s only been suspended a handful of times amidst war and armed rebellion, including during the Civil War and, most recently, after the attack on Pearl Harbor. Even then, the courts challenged or curtailed aspects of those suspensions as unconstitutional.
Yet according to reports, Stephen Miller and his circle wanted to invoke those historical analogies, though not to repel an invading army. White House aides considered having the president just declare that habeas corpus no longer applied to certain categories of migrants, which would have hypothetically allowed DHS agents to round up anyone they suspected of being in the United States illegally and send them out of the country, without those arrested individuals being allowed to challenge their imprisonment and without a judge having the chance to weigh in.
Apparently, even some officials inside the Trump administration found this alarming, and the proposal was put on hold. But the danger hasn’t passed.
An administration that has considered erasing a foundational constitutional right — by merely declaring it void — has demonstrated quite clearly to the American people that it’s got an appetite for erasing others. Indeed, the New York Times reporting makes clear that the extreme measures didn’t stop at habeas corpus. The same faction inside the White House also pushed to invoke the Insurrection Act to crush anti-Trump protests with federal troops, a possibility I’ve been warning about since I quit the first Trump administration.
All of these “ideas” remain possible actions this White House may take in the years to come. So what on earth could stop them? For now, the answer is provided by the same document that Trump and his aides considered tossing in the trash. The U.S. Constitution itself. The court system — outlined in Article III of the founding document — has shown itself more resilient than expected against Trump’s ongoing crime spree.
America’s judges are the thin and unglamorous barrier between the rest of us and a constitution-wrecking colossus. Just this month, Trump has absorbed one judicial humiliation after another. A federal judge made him scrape his name off the Kennedy Center, ruling that only Congress can name it. Another ordered him to restore the slavery and climate exhibits he’d stripped from our national parks, accusing his administration of trying to rewrite the nation’s history “with a white-out pen.” And any day now the Supreme Court is expected to tell him that he cannot simply cancel another part of the U.S. Constitution, which protects birthright citizenship.
The courts are holding for now. But that’s not the main story.
The story is still that there’s a man in the White House willing to literally cancel parts of the Constitution the moment they inconvenience him. He’s also got a circle around him hunting for the next opening. Against the seriousness of this anti-constitutional threat, judges can only do so much. The rest is on us. And we can only successfully hold the line by naming what they are doing, by refusing to be numbed by it, and by never, for a single day, wavering in our defiance against it.
Stories like this shouldn’t be ignored because they’re scary. They should be shared. They should be a rallying cry. My long-held view is that if you want to stand on the right side of history, you must stand up.
Your friend, in defiance,
Miles Taylor
P.S. Help spread the defiance by sharing this post.
THE DEFIANCE WATCHLIST
We are tracking these stories today.
U.S. AND IRAN STRIKE A “DEAL.” IT COULD BE THE WORST IN U.S. DIPLOMATIC HISTORY. According to reports, the two sides have reached an agreement to end the three-month war, with Trump ordering an end to the U.S. naval blockade on the Strait of Hormuz and the regime allegedly agreeing to reopen it to commerce. Details are set to come later this week, but early reports suggest Iran may get $24 billion in unfrozen assets as part of the agreement, in exchange for making promises it already made in a nuclear agreement struck with the Obama administration more than a decade ago. If that’s the case, then the Trump administration took America to war with Iran… spent billions and upended the global economy… and only made its adversary stronger, richer, and more capable of entrenching itself in power indefinitely. Mission accomplished?
TRUMP’S “HISTORY ERASER” GETS SHOT DOWN. A federal judge has temporarily blocked a Trump order meant to rewrite history exhibits at national parks across the United States. In a devastating ruling, the judge wrote: “Under the guise of promoting American dignity, this Administration seeks to share a limited history by ordering the removal of all signs, displays, and interpretive exhibits at National Parks that do not align with its preferred narrative, thereby telling half-truths.” Indeed, as a result of the order, government workers used crowbars to remove an exhibit in Philadelphia about slaves owned by the nation’s first president, George Washington. The judge ordered that the restoration be complete by July 3, ahead of the nation’s 250th birthday.
ACT OF DEFIANCE — DC TURNS TRUMP’S BIRTHDAY PARTY INTO A PROTEST PIT. Trump celebrated his 80th birthday Sunday with UFC fights on the White House lawn, but protesters showed up to crash the party. Demonstrators built their own fake prison cell stuffed with puppet heads of Trump, Bondi, Vance, Patel, Hegseth, and Leavitt. A judge had already tossed a lawsuit to block the event, but that didn’t stop the chants of “Whose house? Our house!”
WHAT’S COMING UP
TONIGHT — DEFIANCE DAILY — Every weeknight @ 5pm ET, you can watch our hour-long podcast LIVE on our DEFIANCE.News page, YouTube, or X — and listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
WEDNESDAY — WEEKLY MISSION BRIEFING — This is the “beating heart of DEFIANCE.org.” Every Wednesday @ 5pm ET we do a special episode of DEFIANCE Daily and announce real actions to combat Trump’s corruption. So tune in. Replays available afterwards.
FRIDAY — WEEKLY COFFEE — Come one, come all! But only Members can ask questions. Join us on Substack or at DEFIANCE.News every Friday at 2p ET. Replays available afterwards.
ADD US TO YOUR CALENDAR — You can access the DEFIANCE.org Google Calendar here. That way, you’ll never miss a meeting, event, or broadcast.
ONE MORE THING
Forward this email to someone who should join the defiance. We are growing the club. I won’t let a wannabe dictator destroy the country I spent my career protecting. That’s why I launched DEFIANCE.org — a club for courageous Americans asking, “WHAT CAN I DO?” Each week, we defy Trump by taking real action to thwart his abuses of power. Become a Member today at DEFIANCE.org/join or here on Substack. 100% of proceeds go to the pro-democracy fight. Or sign up for occasional updates for free below. We publish breaking news and analysis at DEFIANCE.News.
We are fortunate that cooler heads prevailed with regard to habeas corpus, but, as you note, how long will that hold?
As Trump continues to work to amass power our country is in deep danger. We must continue to defy him with all the strength we have and all the legal routes we can take.
Thank you, Miles, for this and all you are making happen. Underlining: "The story is still that there’s a man in the White House willing to literally cancel parts of the Constitution the moment they inconvenience him. He’s also got a circle around him hunting for the next opening. Against the seriousness of this anti-constitutional threat, judges can only do so much. The rest is on us. And we can only successfully hold the line by naming what they are doing, by refusing to be numbed by it, and by never, for a single day, wavering in our defiance against it." Yes! Carry on, People! The rest IS on US! Do all you can...speak up. Write. Show up. Use 5calls app. It matters!